Document control
| Field | Entry |
|---|---|
| Document type | Closed technical consultation draft |
| Version | 0.4 |
| Change history |
|
| Status | Not a standard. Not adopted by REEM ASBL. Not reviewed by lenders, custodians, inspectors or counsel. Not for public conformity claims |
| Owner | Not assigned |
| Basis | Evidence-discipline clauses of the SDASI consultation paper on possession and evidence (v0.7), restated without religious basis; method of the SDASI Disclosure Form (v0.5); CPHAR control model |
Every clause carries one marker:
- [P] Proposed (“shall” states a proposal),
- [X] Parameter (requirement fixed, value left for consultation) or
- [O] Open (a question, not a requirement).
Under clauses, Precedent names an existing document that already covers the clause in whole or in part, and Candidate contribution marks a clause for which no complete equivalent was found in the sources checked; this is not proof of novelty.
1. Purpose and scope
A lender, buyer or investor usually relies on evidence produced by someone else, and an inspection is a snapshot while the decision depends on what happens afterwards. ES-1 sets what that evidence must disclose for reliance between inspections to be informed.
1.1 Scope. Allocated lots of physical metal held in storage (warehouse, vault, bonded area) by one custodian at one location, divided into identified units, whose status may change: financed, released, split, transferred, re-inspected. First application: minor and critical metals. Nothing in the requirements is specific to one metal.
1.2 Excluded from this profile. Commingled or fungible bulk storage and fractional entitlements to a lot. Lot-level physical identifiers do not identify legal fractional interests; these need their own rules (mass balance, entitlement units, legal segregation) in a later profile. MLWR Art. 24(2) permits commingling only as the receipt allows. Under the LPMCL template 7.2, a balance that is not a whole number of bars is held as unallocated metal under a separate agreement, and LPMCL’s disclosable rules 1.4-1.5 state that allocated metal is held as bailee in the holder’s name while an unallocated account is a credit exposure to the custodian. ISO 22095:2020, 5.2, requires mass-balance claims to show how content is calculated and to make clear it may not match the physical content of a product, which is why mass balance belongs in a separate profile.
1.3 Technology-neutral. Requirements are properties of evidence, not specifications of any system, seal, sensor or ledger.
1.4 What ES-1 proposes. A standardised evidence card addressed to identified relying parties, with assertion-level state, explicit search and monitoring perimeters and stated reliance terms. It does not introduce new verification practices: identification, segregation, unique identifiers, record integrity, periodic independent counts and the limits of seal evidence are already addressed by the documents in section 11. For off-warrant metal, LME warehouses report to the Exchange only aggregate quantities of LME-eligible stock by location and metal, with no owner details (LME Warehouse Agreement 6.3.4); this does not prevent bilateral lot-level reporting to a lender under a private agreement, and lenders often contract directly with warehouse operators (MLWR Guide to Enactment, para. 63).
1.5 Out of scope. Legal title and the right of disposal; valuation and price; whether a transaction is permitted (section 7); insurance and guarantees as such; goods in transit (a later profile); assay and sampling methods themselves; adequacy of reserves against issued tokens or claims.
2. Terms
| Term | Meaning in ES-1 |
|---|---|
| Lot | An identified quantity of allocated metal held by one custodian at one location and described by one set of documents |
| Unit | A physically separate part of a lot (crate, drum, bag, bar, pallet) with its own identifier |
| Assertion | One statement in the evidence about a defined population of units (for example: units 001-040 present; seals on units 001-040 intact; net weight of unit 007) |
| Custodian | The party with physical control of the lot (warehouse operator, vault operator, collateral manager) |
| Receipt holder | The person entitled under a warehouse receipt, warrant or equivalent record, in the sense of warehouse-receipt law |
| Release-instructing party | The person whose instruction the custodian accepts to release units |
| Evidence producer | The party that observes and issues primary evidence (inspector, custodian, laboratory, monitoring provider) |
| Compiler | A party that assembles a card from sources it lists, without verifying them |
| Verifier | A party that independently re-performs or checks specified assertions |
| Conformity assessor | A party that assesses whether a card or process conforms to ES-1 |
| Relying party | A party that takes a decision on the basis of the evidence (lender, buyer, investor, issuer) |
| Intended user | A party named on the card as an addressee; naming does not by itself create a legal right of reliance |
| Invalidating event | An event after which a stated assertion is no longer relied upon until re-confirmed (6.2) |
| Lot evidence card | The structured record of the evidence for one lot at one time (section 8) |
3. Identification, segregation and quantity
The lot must be distinguishable from every other asset of the same custodian, down to the unit, and its quantity must reconcile through every split, release and substitution.
3.1 [P] The lot shall be identified by lot identifier, location, list of units and identifiers of the documents relating to it. Precedent: MLWR Arts. 10(1) and 24 (a unique receipt identifier, not necessarily a unit identifier); LPMCL allocated account terms; ISO 22095:2020, 5.3.1.2 and 5.3.2.2 (identity-preserved and segregated models: physical separation and clear identification at every stage, outputs matching inputs). Origin: SDAS v0.7, 1.1.1.
3.2 [P] Each unit shall have an identifier that is not reassigned within an identified namespace and record-retention period. Unit disposition, observed presence, seal state, seal identifiers and seal replacement history shall be recorded as separate attributes, each with its evidence source and observation time. A seal identifier is not a unit identifier; issuance, installation, removal, retention and disposal of each seal are recorded against the seal identifier. Precedent (partial): ISO 18185-1 and -2 (seal ID fixed at manufacture; seal states; read through modified GOST R 55557 adoptions, ISO wording not confirmed); LBMA Good Delivery List Rules 2026, 2.1.5 and packing annex (bar marks, unique box references); ASTM F946-85(2024) (accountability of uniquely numbered seals from manufacture to disposal; publisher scope only). Origin: CPHAR seal model.
3.3 [P] For form, grade or purity and weights, the evidence shall state whether each value was measured (by whom, when, how) or declared (by whom). Precedent: MLWR Art. 12; LME Warehouse Agreement 2.1.1 (visual inspection, no assay at intake).
3.4 [P] Splits, merges and partial releases shall be recorded as parent-child links between lots. Quantity shall reconcile at unit level: opening, plus received, minus released, plus or minus documented adjustments, equals closing. Exceptions are logged, and assertions about released quantities are retired. Precedent (partial): MLWR Arts. 27-28; ISO 22095:2020, 6.9 (inventory accounting: opening stock, inputs received, inputs and outputs on hand, outputs delivered, reconciled per reporting period) and 6.8 (conversion factors).
3.5 [P] Substitution, repacking, sampling, melting or refining of any unit shall be recorded with the replacement identifiers. Precedent (partial): LPMCL Allocated Account Agreement template (2018, file of November 2023), 4.5: the client authorises the custodian “at any time and for any reason” to exchange its bars for “the same number of substitute bars of like quality”, with the bar records replaced. An allocated lot can therefore change bar by bar without the holder’s prior consent; a card must record each substitution.
3.6 [P] Where identification has not been achieved, the evidence shall say so and shall not describe the lot in terms that imply identification. Origin: SDAS v0.7, 1.1.2.
4. Custody, control and claims
The evidence must say who controls the lot, who can release it, who bears its risk and what was found about claims against it, within a stated search, without passing any of this off as title.
4.1 [P] The evidence shall name the custodian and the basis of its control (warehouse contract, custody or collateral management agreement), with document reference and date. Precedent: MLWR; LPMCL; LME Warehouse Agreement.
4.2 [P] The evidence shall name the release-instructing party, state whether the custodian has agreed in writing to honour release permits issued by or for a third party, and state whether the custodian’s acknowledgment of the current receipt holder or relying party (attornment) was obtained, not obtained, not required or is uncertain, under which governing law, with the actual undertaking referenced. Relevant case: Mercuria v Citibank [2015] EWHC 1481 (Comm), where warehouse operators had not acknowledged the transferee (paras. 1, 59-60, 76-77, 158(i): endorsed receipts without the warehouse’s attornment did not perform the delivery obligation under those contracts; judgment read: para. 59, attornment by the warehouse operator is a necessary element of transferring constructive possession and so of delivery, where a third party holds the goods; para. 78, Citi could have issued release instructions asking the operators to attorn; para. 80, the court left open whether section 29(4) of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 excludes contractual deemed delivery). Legal effects vary by law, receipt type and contract. LPMCL template 5.1-5.2: the custodian may act on instructions that appear to be given by the client and assume they are authorised.
4.3 [P] The evidence shall state which party bears the risk of loss or damage and, for any insurance relied on, the insurer, insured party and interest, insured risks, loss payee, limits, validity and evidence source, distinguishing the custodian’s own policy from cover for the owner’s metal; and liability caps, exclusions and any sub-custodian; or that these are not established. A single “insured” flag is not sufficient. Precedent (partial): LPMCL template 12.1 (liability only for negligence, fraud or wilful default, capped at the market value of the balance), 12.3 (no duty to insure unless agreed) and 8.3 (no liability for a sub-custodian except negligent appointment); LME Warehouse Agreement 2.2.4 and 7.1.
4.4 [P] Evidence of custody or control shall not be presented as evidence of ownership or of the right of disposal. Precedent: MLWR Arts. 16-18; LPMCL; Quadra v XL Insurance [2023] EWCA Civ 432, para. 112 (warehouse receipts were evidence that the grain existed, not that the buyer owned it) and para. 122 (insurable interest can exist without a proprietary interest). Origin: SDAS v0.7, 2.1.
4.5 [P] The evidence shall state whether the custodian may lend, pledge, commingle or otherwise use the lot, and shall identify any contractual or statutory lien, right of retention or power of sale exercisable by the custodian or a sub-custodian: its trigger, notice and consent requirements, the assets affected, and the governing instrument and jurisdiction. A right not checked is marked Not established, not absent. Precedent (partial): MLWR Arts. 24-25; LPMCL template 7.2 (segregation from own and other clients’ metal), 4.5 (substitution) and 12.6 (no pledge unless agreed, but a “general lien over all Precious Metals held for you” until all liabilities owed to the custodian, under the agreement or otherwise, are satisfied and, on non-payment, a right to sell “without notice to or consent from you”; sub-custodians may hold their own liens).
4.6 [P] Each change of custody shall record the units handed over, the parties, the time and the condition observed at handover.
4.7 [P] The card shall list instruments, claims and restrictions (receipts, warrants, tokens, liens, unpaid charges, court orders, notified security interests) discovered within an expressly documented search perimeter, and shall identify each issuer, registry and jurisdiction searched, the search method and time, the records accessed and the limitations. Failure to find a record shall not be presented as proof that no unregistered, undisclosed or foreign-law claim exists. Where no search was made, the field states Not searched. Where a register is referenced, the card shall distinguish the entry and search result actually observed from any legal effect attributed to registration; the latter shall cite an identified legal source or be marked Not established. Precedent (partial): MLWR Arts. 10(1)(g) and 25; LME Warehouse Agreement 2.3.7-2.3.8, 3.3.1(d), 3.4.3. Relevant incident: Qingdao, 2014.
4.8 [P] Where the evidence relies on a document issued by another party (receipt, warrant, certificate), it shall state whether that document was authenticated with its issuer, by whom, by what method, when and with what result. For electronic records, signatory authority and revocation status are checked. Relevant case: Natixis v Marex [2019] EWHC 2549 (Comm), forged nickel warehouse receipts.
5. Properties of evidence
Every piece of evidence relied upon must be checkable by someone else, dated twice, explicit about its coverage and limits, clear about who may rely on it, and kept.
5.1 [P] Evidence shall carry an evidence identifier and version, the issuer’s authentication, the verification method, an issuer contact and revocation status, and enough of the underlying record for an independent party to reproduce the check, subject to lawful confidentiality. Precedent: ISRS 4400, para. 13(f) (findings capable of objective verification).
5.2 [P] Evidence shall state, for each assertion, when the condition was observed, when the producer learned of it if later, from when it is effective, and when the evidence was issued, each with its time zone. Later discovery is distinguished from retroactive loss of validity. Candidate contribution (partial): ISRS 4400 paras. 30(n), 30(q) and 33 require timing of procedures where applicable and a report date; paired times per assertion were not found as a requirement.
5.3 [P] Evidence shall distinguish what the producer observed from what it received from another source and did not verify. Precedent: MLWR Art. 12; Intertek Caleb Brett terms, 2 (reliance on customer information without a duty to verify).
5.4 [P] Evidence shall state expressly what it does not establish. Precedent: ISRS 4400, para. 30(d) and (h)-(j); MLWR Art. 12(1)(b).
5.5 [P] Evidence shall name its producer, its role, its relationships to the custodian and relying parties, and any measures of independence. Precedent: ISRS 4400, para. 30(k)-(l); IFIA / TIC Council Compliance Code, Principles 1-2; ISO/IEC 17020:2026, which replaced the 2012 edition (status as reported by reviewers; text not read).
5.6 [P] The procedure by which the evidence is issued shall be documented, versioned and available to the relying party, and the evidence shall cite the version used. Precedent: ISRS 4400, para. 30(n)-(o).
5.7 [P] Alteration after issue shall be detectable; a correction shall be issued as a new version referring to what it corrects. Detectability does not establish signer authority, which is evidenced separately (key validity, authority, revocation). Precedent (partial): MLWR Arts. 6-7; LME Warehouse Agreement 3.1.2 and 4.1; LPMCL template 2.5 (erroneous entries may be reversed and back-valued without prior notice, which a card should record as a new version); ISO 18185-4:2007, 4.3.2 (the event log inside an electronic seal cannot be altered or erased once written; drafters read GOST R 55557.4-2013, a modified adoption, and the ISO clause was confirmed against a published preview by an external check). This covers the seal’s own log, not the integrity of an external evidence card.
5.8 [P] Evidence about contents shall separate what was observed at packing and sealing from assay results, naming the laboratory, the certificate and the unit identifiers the certificate refers to. A certificate that cannot be tied to identified units is recorded as such. Seal integrity shall not be presented as evidence of contents. Precedent: MLWR Art. 12; LME Warehouse Agreement 2.1.1; LME Notice 26/194, section 3.6 (Metal Report linking certificate-of-analysis data to the warrant; per the LME it does not replace producer-issued certificates and the warehouse remains custodian, not originator, of the data; adopted July 2026, effective 1 December 2026). Failure-mode analogue: Trafigura v Gupta [2026] EWHC 159 (Comm), para. 135 (goods in transit).
5.9 [P] Evidence shall state its coverage: units counted, weighed and opened; units inaccessible or unopened; methods, equipment and calibration reference; exceptions found. Precedent: LME Warehouse Agreement 2.1.1-2.1.2, 7.4.3; LBMA Good Delivery List Rules 2026 (dated weight lists, scales with legal-for-trade memory); ISRS 4400.
5.10 [P] Where samples are taken, evidence shall state the sampler, sampling plan, sample identifiers and custody, and the basis for extending results to the lot. Precedent: Intertek Minerals terms (2024), 8.2 and 11.0.
5.11 [P] The card shall distinguish an intended user from a legally enforceable right of reliance. Any required consent, direct engagement, contractual duty, liability cap, time bar, exclusion and governing law shall be stated or marked Not established. Naming a relying party on a card does not create duties, extend insurance or alter delivery rights. Precedent: ISRS 4400, para. 30(b) and (d). Published default terms show why this matters: Intertek Minerals Services Terms and Conditions (2024 version as published) 3.0 and 12.3-12.4, and Intertek’s general terms for countries without local versions (Caleb Brett business line) 3(a), 5 and 8: the general terms bar third-party reliance without Intertek’s prior written consent (8), the Minerals terms control who may instruct the inspector and when a report may be passed to a third party (3.0), and both cap liability at the lesser of a fee multiple or US$15,000 unless otherwise agreed; these are one provider’s defaults, not universal caps; Natixis v Marex, paras. 360-373. Actual effect depends on the executed contract and governing law.
5.12 [P] Evidence and its underlying records shall be retained for a stated period and remain available to relying parties on stated conditions, including if the producer ceases to act. Precedent (partial): LME Warehouse Agreement 4.4 (five years); Intertek Minerals terms 25.0 (seven years); ISO 22095:2020, 6.6.1 (retention set by the supply chain and product life, and the organisation must be able to confirm at any time the status of materials in stock).
6. State of the evidence
State is determined for each assertion and population of units and may be summarised at lot level only if the summary keeps exceptions and coverage. Within interval means only that the specified observation is inside its interval and no invalidating event is known within the stated monitoring perimeter; it does not imply continuous surveillance, an assay, title or absence of unknown claims. Candidate contribution: no equivalent state model was found; warrant validity under exchange rules is a status of an instrument, not of evidence. The court did not propose such a model, but the reasoning in Quadra v XL Insurance [2023] EWCA Civ 432 illustrates why each source must be scrutinised separately: physical presence was weighed from several dated, partly limited observations, separately from title (paras. 25-29, 114-116).
| Axis | Values |
|---|---|
| Physical observation | Observed present · Observed absent · Not observed · Not determined |
| Time validity | Within interval · Expired · Not determined |
| Corroboration | Consistent · Conflicting · Single source or not compared · Not determined |
| Legal claims | Claim or order identified · None identified within stated perimeter · Not searched · Unable to determine |
Custodian acknowledgment is recorded under 4.2, separately from observed presence. State values do not clear any transaction.
6.1 [X] A maximum interval between confirmations shall apply to each assertion type. The evidence shall state the interval, who set it and from when; where none is set, it says so. Value: parameter X1. Precedent: LME Warehouse Agreement 7.4.1 (at least every 12 months, visual inspection and independent count of warranted stock, reported to the Exchange). Origin: SDAS v0.7, 3.3.
6.2 [P] Each invalidating event shall specify its trigger, source, first-known time, affected units and assertions, state changes, deciding party, notification recipients and required re-confirmation. An event changes whether a present condition can still be relied on; it never rewrites an earlier observation, which stays on record as observed at its time. Where notices conflict, the card states which source prevails and why. Default transitions:
| Event | Axes affected | Re-confirmation |
|---|---|---|
| Seal broken without a recorded permit | Physical observation (seal state, presence), Time validity | Affected units: presence, seal, weight |
| Unit missing, or present but not listed | Physical observation, Corroboration | Unit count of the lot |
| Location change without recorded handover | Physical observation, Time validity | Presence at new location |
| Loss of monitoring beyond X2 | Time validity of monitored assertions | Next scheduled or ad hoc observation |
| Notice of competing receipt, warrant, token or claim | Corroboration, Legal claims | Authentication with issuer (4.8), search (4.7) |
| Dispute, seizure or court order | Legal claims | Legal review; physical axes unchanged unless access is lost |
| Change of custodian | Physical observation, Time validity | Handover record (4.6) and count |
| Change of evidence producer | None by itself | Only where a documented dependency or loss of continuity makes earlier observations unreliable |
| Custodian or sub-custodian asserts a lien, suspends release for unpaid charges, or exercises a power of sale | Legal claims; release position; physical observation only if units are actually removed | Validate the notice and governing instrument; confirm affected units and current release position |
| Access for inspection or delivery denied or materially restricted | Time validity of access-dependent assertions; physical observation becomes not currently verifiable, earlier observations preserved; legal claims only if an order is evidenced | Establish reason and scope; re-observe affected units once access is restored. Relevant case: Mercuria v Citibank, para. 113 (storage is not satisfactory if goods cannot be accessed for inspection and delivery) and paras. 27-28 (the independent inspector AHK, appointed by Citi, could not inspect because the port area was declared out of bounds) |
6.3 [P] Where no continuous monitoring covers an assertion, the card shall state Not monitored since last observation, with that time.
6.4 [P] The party that determines each state shall be named, and each determination recorded with its basis. Precedent (partial): LME Warehouse Agreement 2.2.7 and 7.4.2.
6.5 [P] On an invalidating event, the custodian or producer shall notify the intended users recorded for the lot within a stated time (parameter X4), through a stated channel, keeping a receipt log, an escalation route for failed delivery and a version archive. Intended users are recorded with their consent and access rights. Precedent (partial): LME Warehouse Agreement 3.3 and 4.3.2 (notice to the Exchange; holder notified when a warrant must be cancelled).
6.6 [O] Whether electronic monitoring (seal status, location, weight) can extend time validity, and for which assertions. Monitoring of weight and location does not detect substitution with material of the same weight. ISO 18185-4:2007 sets data-protection requirements and physical authentication of seals, but its clause 5.3 does not require that a seal be authenticated electronically through data transmission (read in GOST R 55557.4-2013 and, per an external check, in a published preview of the ISO text). Whether a given seal reading is authenticated must be established from the actual implementation.
7. Separation of evidence from decision
Evidence reports what was observed and when; it never says whether a transaction may proceed.
7.1 [P] Evidence shall state the condition and time observed. It shall not state whether a financing, release, transfer or sale is permitted. Precedent (partial): ISRS 4400, paras. 4 and 6. Origin: SDAS v0.7, 3.4.
7.2 [P] Rules that turn evidence into decisions (for example, no new financing while time validity is Expired) belong to the relying party or a decision system it appoints, and are documented separately.
7.3 [P] The card shall state who pays the evidence producer, any other financial relationship with the parties, and whether any fee, commission or reward depends on the content of the evidence. The fee amount is disclosed to authorised relying parties on request. Candidate contribution, narrowly: not found in the IFIA / TIC Council Compliance Code or Intertek’s published terms; other inspectors’ terms and professional fee rules not checked.
This separation lets several relying parties apply different rules to the same evidence, and lets a decision layer such as CPHAR be audited separately.
8. Lot evidence card
The evidence for a lot is recorded on one card, reissued as a new version at each state change, in a fixed shape so that two compilers produce comparable cards. Origin: method of the SDASI Disclosure Form v0.5. Candidate contribution: structured receipts and certificates exist; field-level confirmation status was not found.
8.1 [P] Four attributes per field, never merged. Value. Confirmation: observed by the producer · received and not verified · checked and silent · not checked · not established. Applicability: applicable · not applicable, with the ground · not yet determined. Source: identity, edition, retrieval time, completeness of the copy held, exact location, digest where held, and whether the source is authoritative. “Checked and silent” applies only where the specified version of the source was complete at the stated retrieval time and the named sections were actually inspected; a search result or excerpt is not a checked source.
8.2 [P] Field groups.
| Block | Fields |
|---|---|
| A. Identification and quantity | Lot ID, location, metal, form, grade, weights (measured or declared), units with separate disposition, presence and seal attributes, parent-child links, reconciliation |
| B. Custody and claims | Custodian, basis document, release-instructing party, permit honouring, acknowledgment status, risk and insurance, re-use terms, search perimeter and results, authentication results |
| C. Roles | Evidence producer, compiler, verifier, conformity assessor: names, scopes, relationships, independence, procedures and versions, payer and contingency status |
| D. State | Per assertion: four axes with time, basis and deciding party; interval and its authority; monitoring perimeter; events since last observation |
| E. Contents | Coverage, sealing witness, sampling, laboratory, certificate and its unit links |
| F. Reliance and retention | Intended users, rights of reliance and their source, consent, caps, time bars, governing law, notification channel, retention |
| G. Limits | What this card does not establish; cannot be left blank |
8.3 [P] Roles. A third-party compilation is not an independent verification. The card shall identify the evidence producer, any compiler, any verifier and any conformity assessor, each with its procedure and scope. Where a compiler combines several producers’ reports, each assertion names the producer that observed it; the compiler is never shown as having observed the goods. Origin: SDASI Disclosure Form, Modes A and B, refined after expert review.
8.4 [O] The exact field list will be fixed only after worked cards have been completed (section 10).
9. Conformance and independence
REEM ASBL writes ES-1 and does not assess conformance with it; this is a governance choice, not an innovation.
9.1 [P] REEM ASBL is not a party to any transaction and does not assess any party’s conformance.
9.2 [P] A conformity claim shall state what it concerns: completeness of the card against ES-1, operation of the issuing process, or independently verified physical assertions, and who made it. Illustrative wording, usable only if ES-1 is adopted: “Card prepared in accordance with REEM ES-1, version [x], as to [scope]. REEM ASBL has not verified the content.” No conformity may be claimed against this draft.
9.3 [P] No REEM mark is issued under this draft.
9.4 [P] Conformance with ES-1 does not establish that the lot exists, is of the stated quality, is free of claims or that any financing against it is safe. Precedent: ISO 22095:2020, clause 1 (a chain-of-custody system cannot by itself substantiate claims).
10. Parameters, open questions and tests before consultation
Four values and four questions decide whether ES-1 is usable; none can be settled without lenders, custodians, inspectors and counsel.
| ID | Question | Who should answer |
|---|---|---|
| X1 | Maximum interval between confirmations, by assertion type, metal and storage | Lenders, insurers, inspectors |
| X2 | Period of lost monitoring after which monitored assertions expire | Lenders, monitoring providers |
| X3 | Re-confirmation scope after each event type (6.2) | Lenders, inspectors |
| X4 | Notification time and channel after an invalidating event | Lenders, custodians |
| O1 | Rules for fractional entitlements (excluded from this profile) | Lenders, counsel |
| O2 | Rules for commingled storage (excluded from this profile) | Custodians, counsel |
| O3 | When a register entry has legal effect under the applicable law, and when it is information only | Counsel, per jurisdiction |
| O4 | Can monitoring extend time validity (6.6)? | Lenders, monitoring providers |
Tests before consultation.
- Two anonymised worked cards for an allocated, sealed lot at one warehouse, taken through a timeline: receipt, sampled assay, reweighing, partial release, seal break, transfer to a new warehouse, competing pledge notice, inspector exit, court seizure, a failed release attempt and a notice of custodian insolvency. For the last two, show which assertions change state, which do not, and which questions need a separate legal opinion. Show state changes per assertion, notifications, version chain, authentication and reliance terms; an outside reviewer rebuilds the card from its source register.
- Review by 3-5 warehouse-finance lenders, 2 custodians or collateral managers, 2 inspection companies and counsel in two storage jurisdictions: does the card change a credit, release or audit decision, and which field cannot be supplied in practice?
Checks still open: ISO 22095 Amd 1:2026; original ISO 17712, ISO 18185 (especially part 4), ISO/IEC 17020:2026 and ASTM F946 texts; SGS, Cotecna, Bureau Veritas and Alex Stewart terms; the MLWR Guide to Enactment on registries; representative executed collateral and stock monitoring agreements; the law of target storage jurisdictions on security interests, warehouse liens, attornment and electronic possession.
11. Relation to other documents, cases and sources
ES-1 sits on top of the documents below. It claims no conformity with any of them, and where they cover a clause, the clause says so.
Where the original ISO text was not accessible, the drafters used identified Russian national adoptions. GOST R ISO 22095-2023 is identical (IDT) to ISO 22095:2020; GOST R 55557.1-.4-2013 are modified (MOD) adoptions of ISO 18185. Findings from modified adoptions are not presented as the wording or clause numbering of the ISO originals unless separately confirmed. No conformity with any ISO standard is claimed.
| Document | What it already covers | How checked |
|---|---|---|
| UNCITRAL-UNIDROIT Model Law on Warehouse Receipts (2024) and Guide to Enactment | Receipt contents, sealed goods “said to contain”, segregation and commingling, electronic receipts, duty of care, delivery; registry options and lender practice in the Guide | Arts. 6-7, 10, 12, 23-24, 26-29 and Guide paras. 47, 63, 90-91 read. Binding only where enacted |
| ISRS 4400 (Revised) | Objective verifiability, disclosed procedures, factual findings without conclusions, addressee and purpose | Full text read: paras. 4-6, 13(f), 30, 33 |
| LME Warehouse Agreement (April 2026) and Notice 26/194 | Visual check versus assay, periodic independent counts, duplicates, notices, retention, off-warrant aggregate reporting; Metal Report | Clauses 2.1-2.3, 3.1-3.4, 4.3-4.4, 6.3.4, 7.1, 7.4 read. Metal Report adopted 31 July 2026, effective 1 December 2026, not yet in force at the date of this draft. LME-warranted metal only |
| LPMCL allocated account terms | Allocated versus unallocated metal, bailment, substitution, insurance | Allocated and unallocated templates and the disclosable schedule of rules (27 April 2023) read: 2.5 reversals, 4.5 substitution, 5.1-5.2 instructions, 7.2-7.4 segregation, ownership and location, 8 sub-custodians, 12.1-12.6 liability, insurance and liens; rules 1.4-1.5. Templates, not executed terms |
| IFIA / TIC Council Compliance Code (4th ed., 2018) | Integrity, independence, impartiality, conflicts of interest | Read; no fee rule |
| Intertek Minerals terms (2024) and Caleb Brett terms (countries without local versions) | Principal-only reliance, liability caps, sample limits, claim windows, retention | Read; published default terms, actual engagements may differ |
| ISO/IEC 17020:2026 | Competence and impartiality of inspection bodies | Catalogue status as reported by external reviewers; text not read |
| ISO 22095:2020 and Amd 1:2026 | Chain-of-custody terms and models | Full text read through the identical (IDT) GOST R ISO 22095-2023, including models 5.2-5.4 and requirements 6.6-6.9; Amd 1:2026 (one page) not read. ISO 22095:2020 is marked for revision (ISO/CD 22095-1 is a draft). ISO 22095-2:2026 (mass balance) and ISO 22095-3:2026 (book and claim), which address transparency, communication and claims for models excluded from this profile, known from the ISO catalogue as reported by an external audit |
| ISO 18185-1, -2, -4; ISO 17712:2013; ASTM F1157, F1158, F946, F832 | Electronic and mechanical seals | ISO 18185 read through modified GOST R 55557 adoptions; ISO 17712 and the ASTM guides: publisher scope only. ISO 21976 (medicinal packaging) is an analogy only |
| LBMA Good Delivery List Rules 2026 | Bar identification, packing, weight lists, scales | Good Delivery Rules read. Gold Bar Integrity: refiner reporting operating in 2026; custodian aggregate reporting targeted for end-2026 and bar-level custodian reporting intended for 2027 (LBMA timeline, reported by audit); schema not seen |
Non-normative analytical context. PwC, Global Crypto Regulation Report 2027 (October 2026), pp. 13–17, discusses evidence gaps, transaction dependencies, the legal effect of registers and accountable automation in digital-finance infrastructure. It is not a stored-metal evidence standard, not a source of obligations under ES-1 and not an endorsement of REEM.
Cases. None shows that ES-1 would have prevented a loss; each is fact-specific.
| Case | What happened | ES-1 clauses | How checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Qingdao, 2014; Mercuria v Citibank [2015] EWHC 1481 (Comm) | Metal repo’d on Qingdao receipts (US$270m) may not have existed or was pledged several times; receipts endorsed in blank did not deliver without the warehouse’s acknowledgment | 4.2, 4.4, 4.7 | Judgment read (22 May 2015): paras. 1-3 (27 sets of receipts for aluminium and copper in Qingdao, Penglai and Shanghai; metal possibly missing or multiply pledged), 59-60, 76-80, 113, 158. The court did not decide whether the metal existed, who owned it or the extent of multiple pledging |
| Natixis v Marex [2019] EWHC 2549 (Comm) | Forged nickel receipts; authentication duty owed to Marex, which requested it, not to Natixis, which never received it (paras. 360-373); Marex’s damages cut 25% (para. 472) | 4.4, 4.8, 5.11 | Judgment read |
| Trafigura v Gupta [2026] EWHC 159 (Comm) | About US$500m paid for 107 cargoes sold as nickel that did not contain nickel; certificates could not be tied to cargoes without inspection (para. 135) | 3.3, 5.8, 5.9, 5.10 | Judgment read; goods in transit, an analogue only |
| LME Notice 23/044 (17 March 2023) | Nine nickel warrants invalidated at one facility; found by bag weight; off-warrant owners urged to check own stock | 3.3, 5.8, 6.2 | Notice read |
| Quadra v XL Insurance [2023] EWCA Civ 432 | Grain fraud with warehouse receipts issued to several traders for the same grain. The court found physical presence on the balance of probabilities from a visual inspection without sampling, separate SGS and Bureau Veritas inspections 40 days before and 6 days after the receipt, and partial deliveries as corroboration; inspectors’ reliance on elevator documents went to title, not to physical quantity (paras. 25-29, 114-116) | 5.4, 6 | Judgment read (Court of Appeal, 21 April 2023). Grain, not metal |
SDASI. ES-1 restates, without religious basis, the evidence-discipline clauses of the SDASI consultation paper. Questions of Islamic law stay with SDASI and qualified scholars.
Claims to avoid: “the first standard for physical inventory proof”; “title or metal guaranteed by seal”; “lenders have no recourse” as a general statement; “compliant with ISO 22095, ISO 17712 or ISO/IEC 17020” without the full texts and a formal conformity analysis.
Internal sources: SDAS consultation paper v0.7; SDASI Disclosure Form rev. 0.5; SDASI Standards Programme rev. 0.3; CPHAR pitch v5; two gap analyses of draft 0.1 and an independent expert review of draft 0.3 (6 November 2026).